MLB Trade Deadline Winners and Losers: Padres go all-in, Angels fold

By Pedro Moura
FOX Sports activities MLB Author

Baseball’s most aggressive common managers made essentially the most aggressive strikes of the deadline.

San Diego’s A.J. Preller acquired famous person Juan Soto and a bunch of different impression gamers, and Seattle’s Jerry Dipoto went all-in so as to add right-hander Luis Castillo.

Everybody else tinkered based on their positions within the standings — besides the Rockies, in fact, who made no trades in any respect. They’d qualify as losers in our listing of groups that follows, however can you actually lose in case you do not take part?

Of the groups who made trades forward of the annual deadline, right here is our fast learn of who fared greatest and worst.


1. San Diego Padres

In Soto, they acquired a famous person at little price to their present squad. All their different additions characterize clear enhancements, too, regardless of the Padres’ unconventional maneuver of primarily parting with the incumbent in alternate for his alternative.

New first baseman Josh Bell is a much better hitter than both Eric Hosmer or Luke Voit, each of whom the Padres surrendered Tuesday. New nearer Josh Hader is a greater pitcher than Taylor Rogers, whom he changed. Late-blooming utility man Brandon Drury isn’t any certainty, however he is a very good guess to at the very least hit left-handed pitching, and the Padres look adequate now that these marginal enhancements may make the last word distinction come October.

How Juan Soto strengthens Padres batting lineup and dynamic

How Juan Soto strengthens Padres batting lineup and dynamic

Former MLB participant and present San Diego Padres broadcaster Tony Gwynn Jr. joins Colin Cowherd to interrupt down the Juan Soto commerce.

2. New York Yankees

They did it in considerably much less flashy vogue, however the Yankees additionally buttressed their roster with out considerably hindering their future. In actual fact, there’s an argument that they aided it.

Proper-hander Frankie Montas, their prize acquisition, has pitched like an elite No. 2 starter at occasions, and if he is wholesome, New York has an ideal match to comply with Gerrit Cole within the playoff rotation — this yr and subsequent.

What the Yankees wanted was pitching upside, not pitching depth. So it made sense, then, that they traded Jordan Montgomery to St. Louis for injured outfielder Harrison Bader. Evidently, they had been assured they’d not need Montgomery to begin a playoff sport for them.

Bader’s acquisition is smart for a similar purpose. He might not play till September, however the Yankees need not care about August. Twelve video games up of their division, they care about October.

New York Yankees the largest winners of MLB commerce deadline?

New York Yankees the biggest winners of MLB trade deadline?

Ben Verlander breaks down why the New York Yankees had been the massive winners of the MLB commerce deadline.

3. Cincinnati Reds

That is the primary time the Reds are even arguably deadline winners in a very long time. Normal supervisor Nick Krall operated from a robust place, and he wielded it effectively to deal each Luis Castillo and Tyler Mahle for vital packages of prospects.

The expertise pool they introduced again is sufficiently big that it might alter the Reds’ trajectory — not this yr or subsequent, however maybe in 2024 or 2025. Castillo and Mahle weren’t leases, however Krall was good to appreciate that they weren’t going to be a part of the subsequent good Reds crew with out signing extensions. 


1. Chicago Cubs

Inexplicably, Chicago traded solely relievers. And never solely rental relievers, both. Breakout right-hander Scott Effross has many extra years of management remaining, however it’s the Yankees who management his rights now. If he turns into one other New York reduction ace, the Cubs must clarify why they held onto gamers who is not going to be a part of their future as a substitute of gamers who might.

Retaining outfielder Ian Happ is not loopy, relying on what the Cubs do that offseason. However maintaining Willson Contreras defies simple clarification. It is troublesome to imagine he couldn’t have fetched greater than the compensation decide the Cubs will get when he leaves this offseason.

2. Los Angeles Angels

The Angels acted late and decisively in buying and selling Brandon Marsh, Raisel Iglesias, and Noah Syndergaard in a two-hour span simply forward of Tuesday’s deadline. The selections netted them a pair prospects, most notably catcher Logan O’Hoppe, however largely monetary flexibility. The strikes would encourage extra confidence in the event that they weren’t the exact inversion of strikes that had been meant to encourage confidence final offseason. 

5 months in the past, then-manager Joe Maddon was talking of Marsh because the membership’s heart fielder of the longer term, performing as if Mike Trout would quickly transfer to a nook. Iglesias, simply signed to a four-year deal, was presupposed to grow to be the middle of the membership’s bullpen. Normal supervisor Perry Minasian spoke of Syndergaard, a high-priced gamble, as if he had been the identical degree of expertise as Trout himself.

As a substitute, Marsh did not hit however did play elite protection whereas Iglesias and Syndergaard every fell considerably wanting expectations. Minasian hit reset Tuesday. However is there sufficient time for one more retool earlier than Shohei Ohtani turns into a free agent?

3. Baltimore Orioles

It made little sense to select now, essentially the most thrilling time for the franchise in six years, to commerce away the crew’s hottest participant and lone All-Star. Positive, they netted a number of pitching prospects for outfielder Trey Mancini and nearer Jorge López, however did they meaningfully enhance? And both manner, at what price? López stays below membership management for 2 extra seasons. Is not the purpose to win someday quickly?

Pedro Moura is the nationwide baseball author for FOX Sports activities. He beforehand lined the Dodgers for 3 seasons for The Athletic and, earlier than that, the Angels and Dodgers for 5 seasons for the Orange County Register and L.A. Occasions. Extra beforehand, he lined his alma mater, USC, for The son of Brazilian immigrants, he grew up within the Southern California suburbs. His first e book, “How to Beat a Broken Game,” got here out this spring. Comply with him on Twitter @pedromoura.

Get extra from Main League Baseball Comply with your favorites to get details about video games, information and extra.